A version of this post was published on Substack on May 08, 2026
Alan Kohler is right when he says that AI is probably the most powerful product in history. It can give you a new “friend” for a small fee, and it seems it might make corporations more productive. His analysis published in ABC News on 7 May 2026 is sharp and the framing useful. It ranges across AI consciousness, social media addiction, and the corporate logic driving it all. You can read it here.
There is, however, a cost side to this ledger that isn’t appearing in any company’s accounts.. Until we name it clearly, we will keep reaching for the wrong regulatory tools.
The missing cost is social infrastructure.
We are comfortable thinking about physical infrastructure such as roads, ports, and the power grid. This is what markets depend on and it is indispensable to contemporary living. We do not let private entities degrade them without consequence, because we understand that the economy runs on them.
Social infrastructure works the same way. Trust, reputation, networks, and shared meaning are what economic exchange depends on just as surely as roads and ports. Social infrastructure has no single owner and no single regulator. Its value doesn’t appear on any balance sheet and no-one is issuing invoices to pay for any overall degradation. This is precisely why markets fail to price it and why the companies doing the degrading carry none of the cost.
The costs of AI’s erosion of our stockpiles of social capital are landing on society, while the profits from its deployment stay private.
This is what AI is doing, and the mechanism is more specific than mimicry or individual addiction.
AI-generated positioning moves, together with its capacity for tireless companionship, validation, and apparent expertise, are flooding the social market. These interactions look like genuine social exchange but carry no underlying social investment. Nobody is actually building trust. Nobody is truly extending their reputation into a relationship. Humans bring genuine social investment to these exchanges. What comes back looks like reciprocity but it isn’t. The social glue simply isn’t there. I call this phantom social capital.
The correct economic analogy is not addiction, as suggested by Alan Kohler. It is counterfeiting. The harm is not just to individuals who receive fake money. It is to the currency system itself.
Kohler notes that AI simultaneously provides pseudo-friendship to individuals and productivity infrastructure to corporations, and treats these as adjacent phenomena. However, they are the same phenomenon at different scales. The same technology that is flooding individual social markets with counterfeit currency is concentrating the economic returns in a small number of firms. That is a classic externality structure of private gains and socialised costs, with no correcting mechanism in sight.
This matters for the regulatory question Kohler raises, because addiction regulation and infrastructure regulation are not the same thing.
Addiction regulation protects individuals from harmful products. It is the right framework for cigarettes and gambling, and arguably social media algorithms. In contrast, infrastructure regulation protects shared foundations from private exploitation. We have well-developed frameworks for this such as environmental law, food and medicine regulations, and financial services risk regulation. We reach for these tools when the companies building and deploying these systems generate returns by degrading something the whole economy depends on.
The frameworks exist. What is missing is the recognition that AI’s erosion of social infrastructure is the kind of damage they were built to address.
The question is whether we will make that recognition in time.
Melanie James is an independent researcher working at the intersection of positioning theory, social capital, and artificial intelligence. She explores what AI is doing to the social foundations of human life.