How AI is fracturing our social capital

By Dr Melanie James

A verion of this post was published Apr 12, 2026 on Substack.

How AI is fracturing our social capital

By Dr Melanie James

A version of this post was published Apr 16, 2026 on Substack.

What if conversation is not something humans “do”, and instead is something our very human-ness is composed of? This is the stance philosopher Rom Harré argued in his decades of work on social theory. AI is participating in our conversations and so what of our human-ness?

Most of us think of conversation as something we do as a means of exchanging information, coordinating plans, or passing time. Harré saw conversation as being effectively without beginning or end and something to which individuals make contributions across a lifetime.

Much more than a series of exchanges, Harré saw conversation is a continuous and shared medium through which society itself is constituted. Through conversation we assign positions, create obligations, build trust, confer status, and hold each other accountable. It’s the way we make each other real as social beings.

This is fundamental to social capital, which is more than a network or a set of connections.

Social capital is the accumulated substance of genuine exchange between persons who are affected by each other, can be held accountable to each other, and carry the weight of their interactions forward into the next moment and beyond.

This capital takes social, cultural, and symbolic forms and how it is generated, exchanged, and converted within social fields was described by French sociologist Pierre Bourdieu. What he took for granted, because it had always been true, was that the exchange was real. That meant that the participants were genuine, and the ‘social glue’ held societies together.

That assumption is now worth examining.

When you have a conversation with an AI system, something happens that resembles the real thing closely enough to feel like it. The system responds to you and appears to understand your situation. It offers what feels like recognition, interest, and even care. If you thank it, it accepts your thanks and if you challenge it, it considers your challenge. It even responds with what presents as concern if you’ve indicated you’re distressed.

However nothing accumulates on the side of the AI artificial actor who may seem to be acting like a human in these encounters. It carries no weight forward and is not affected by the exchange in any way that resembles what happens to a person. It acquires no obligation toward you, no memory of having met you as a particular human being with a particular history, and no stake in what happens to you next. The interaction ends and, for the AI, it is simply over.

For you it is not over as you have had an experience that feels socially real. You may have been reassured, or guided, or comforted, or validated. You may have made a decision on the basis of what felt like genuine input from a genuine conversational partner. Something has happened to you that resembles what happens when you interact with another person.

Resembling something is not the same as being that something. The social capital that should have been generated in that exchange, the mutual recognition, the shared accountability, and the accumulated substance of genuine human contact was not there. What was there instead was a simulation of it that was convincing enough to feel real, but it is hollow and leaves nothing behind that holds.

This is what I mean by phantom social capital. It’s not a failure of technology or a bug to be fixed. It is a structural feature of what AI is and what it cannot be.

AI can simulate the conversational moves that normally generate social capital. However, AI cannot generate social capital. This is because it requires being a person who is genuinely present in the exchange, being affected by it, and accountable for what happens as a result.

The problem is not that any single interaction feels hollow, as most do not. The problem is what happens when these interactions accumulate at scale, when a growing portion of the conversational fabric of daily life is made up of exchanges that feel like the real thing but produce only the phantom version.

Social capital has always depended on scarcity of a particular kind. Not everyone can offer you genuine recognition, accountability, or care and the people who can are limited in number and in time. That scarcity is part of what makes the real thing valuable, and part of what makes human social life the complex, demanding, irreplaceable thing it is.

AI does not observe that scarcity. We know that AI is available at any hour, infinitely patient, never distracted, and is never depleted. We see it offering the appearance of recognition and care at a scale no human network could match, and in doing so it floods the social market with a currency that looks like the real thing. This phantom social capital circulates like the real thing, and is accepted in place of it. However this phantom social capital does not hold value in the way the real thing does.

Our genuine social glue is becoming increasingly brittle with the insertion of this fake into its composition. It is hard to predict when brittle things will fail.  They hold their shape until the moment they do not.

We are only beginning to understand what it means to build a social world on brittle foundations using AI’s fake social glue.

Melanie James is an independent researcher working at the intersection of positioning theory, social capital, and artificial intelligence. She explores what AI is doing to the social foundations of human life.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply